Note: This is another in my sequence of post-Mystery-Hunt cryptics, which started with "Still There," "Post-Game Predictions," "The Sequel," "Power Lines," "A Lesson in Cryptography," "Yet More Villainy," "Further Escapades," and "Time X*X"; this one was written before the 2012 hunt and refers to the 2011 hunt.
Mamma Mia! When Mario and Princess Peach went down to NYC for their honeymoon, Peach got kidnapped again, causing much confusion. (Specifically, in half of the Down clues, one word in the definition part is confused and must recover before the clue can be solved; for the other half, the answer itself gets confused before being entered.) As before, you must help Mario search for Peach through several successive video game worlds, scoring points along the way.
World 1: As you enter Across answers, two hostile entities will unexpectedly emerge from the grid; you must encage them in multiple boxes like the one attached to the top left corner of the grid. In addition, most Across clues are "mistaken," in that the string of letters clued by the wordplay has one incorrect letter; the correct letters (in clue order) will say what games these entities are from.
Unfortunately, because of all of these mistakes, you get no points for completing this round.
Total current points: ___0___.
World 2: One unclued column in the grid indicates what "third-person shooter" video game this world corresponds to; the other says where you and your opponent must be for you to exit it. You can already see a couple of possible positions for each of you; draw the paths of the three shortest shots that might occur, assuming you and your opponent always get hit exactly in the middle of the broadest side.
Your score when you exit (if you don't know it yet) can be found by looking where the unclued columns intersect Across answers with non-mistaken clues; either the larger score or the smaller score is yours.
Total current points: _______.
World 3: The incorrect letters from World 1, in clue order, form an appropriate two-word phrase indicating how the entities from World 1, and the game from World 2, combine to give the names of the two creatures from World 3 who have unexpectedly teamed up to kidnap Peach. Find all grid squares that touch, at a lower corner and nowhere else, the combined set of paths from World 2, and circle the letters inside to get a set of appropriate objects.
Use these circled letters to extract letters from the clues as follows: If any entry (Across or Down) has a circled letter in position n, take the nth letter of the corresponding clue. If you read the letters extracted from Across clues, and then those extracted from the Down clues, both in "natural order" (the order in which you encounter the objects used to obtain them, when traveling as you normally would) you will find out what to do with the objects to defeat the creatures; this will, of course, get you more points.
Total current points: _______.
Final Runaround: Get to the one place where you can perform this action without any letters getting in the way, and perform it. Your current position now holds the defeated creatures, Peach and a sign (feel free to draw them all in, if you want). For each Across clue that intersects a circled letter, use its noncircled letters to extract letters from Down clues (wherever possible) using the same technique as before, in "natural order"; the resulting letter sequences, again in "natural order," will tell you what is written on the sign. Then do this again with "Across" and "Down" reversed; this will describe the audio you are now hearing, and will also give the wordplay part of a clue telling who the next Big Boss is…
1. Eyeglasses worn by a smiley bagel-tossing baboon overturning a
monkey bread tree
5. A tie-twisting comedian named Fey
10. Beginners in area now should look into another British region
11. Dad initially lit into Cobb in a trite manner
12. Hope provided by substitutes for the substitutes' substitutes?
13. Golden Girls's first and last bacchanal
14. Stashed in a tomb with remarkably inert communist
16. Ripken from the Orioles conceals each conspiracy
17. Straitlaced couple that start promoting Quakerism outwardly
19. P-predecessor interrupts Ms. Thurman in misdirected Gypsy
20. Amber ne'er leaves odd items behind for repair
21. A feline's utterances, uttered for artistic inspiration
23. Topless dinners will be stimulating things
26. Replaced puny Daisy's forerunner?
27. Actress Dennings keeps very quiet in the middle of Elektra
28. Unloosed Mo & Eloise, being starved for company
31. Forsooth, apple's peel is a source of minerals
32. Conjoined with another word, it means "not-quite-retro author Bellow"
33. The Gallic diarist Anais is a noted Marxist
34. Schilling and closer almost submit (2 wds.)
35. A shadeless part of the woods disheartened French author André
36. Mustn't, ultimately, look at clothing 'til tailors sew it together
DOWN1. Manipulate a nib to produce word before "Birth" in the name of a Jewish service organization (1'3)